What types of surgical robots exist?

The types of surgical robots are diverse, reflecting the variety of surgical procedures they assist. We can broadly classify these robotic systems into three categories:

• Supervisory-controlled systems
• Telesurgical systems
• Shared-control systems

Supervisory-controlled systems

Supervisory-controlled systems, or autonomous robotic systems, are pre-programmed devices capable of performing surgery independently once the surgeon sets the plan.

These systems use a combination of 3D imaging, preoperative surgical planning, and precise execution of that plan, all without human intervention during the actual procedure. These robots are often used in procedures requiring extreme precision such as orthopedic surgeries for joint replacement.

Telesurgical systems

Telesurgical systems, or remote surgery systems, enable surgeons to perform procedures from a distance. The surgeon uses a console to control the robot's movements, which mimics the surgeon's hand movements in real-time to carry out the operation.

These systems often incorporate advanced features like haptic feedback, allowing the surgeon to feel tissue resistance during surgery. This type of robot is typically used in complex and minimally invasive surgeries such as cardiovascular and neurological procedures.

Shared-control systems

Shared-control systems are an amalgamation of the surgeon's expertise and the robot's precision. In these systems, the surgeon actively performs the surgery while the robotic system provides stability and support. The robot only intervenes when it detects unstable or imprecise movements. Ophthalmic surgeries often employ shared-control systems, as these procedures demand exceptional precision and stability.

Each type of surgical robot has a unique role in operating rooms, expanding the horizons of what is possible in surgery. Through different levels of interaction and control, these robots enhance surgical precision, stability, and flexibility, thereby pushing the boundaries of traditional surgical techniques.

Advantages of surgical robots

There are several key benefits that these advanced systems bring to the operating room:

• Enhanced precision and control
• More opportunities for minimally invasive surgeries
• Reduced physical strain on surgeons
• Increased reach and maneuverability

Enhanced precision and control

The first and perhaps most significant advantage lies in the precision and control that these robotic systems offer. With high-definition 3D visualization and scaled, filtered, tremor-free movement of instruments, surgeons can perform highly complex procedures with enhanced accuracy. This increased precision is particularly beneficial in surgeries involving delicate or hard-to-reach areas, where the margin for error is exceptionally small.

Increasing opportunities for minimally invasive surgeries

Another advantage is the potential for minimally invasive surgery. Robotic systems often require smaller incisions than traditional open surgery, resulting in less trauma to the patient. This can lead to reduced blood loss, lower risk of infection, shorter hospital stays, and faster recovery times.

Mitigating physical strain

Thirdly, surgical robots can mitigate the physical strain on surgeons. Long and complex procedures can be physically demanding, leading to fatigue and even impacting the surgeon's precision. Robotic systems, however, can help to alleviate this issue by performing the physically taxing aspects of the surgery.

Greater reach and maneuverability

Finally, surgical robots allow for greater reach and maneuverability. The articulating robotic arms can rotate and bend far beyond the natural range of human hands. This allows surgeons to perform complex procedures in tight spaces and at angles that would be challenging, or even impossible, with traditional surgical methods. This limits the number and size of incisions that surgeons must make to operate.

The introduction of surgical robots into the operating room has the potential to revolutionize surgical practice. The technology offers increased precision and control, facilitates minimally invasive procedures, reduces physical strain on surgeons, and expands the boundaries of what is surgically possible.

Limitations of surgical robots

While the advantages of surgical robots are transformative, it's crucial to shed light on their limitations as well. Their primary limitations today include:

• High costs
• Steep learning curve
• Increased surgery duration
• Legal and regulatory concerns

Costs

Firstly, the significant initial and ongoing costs of these systems pose a considerable financial burden. Up-front costs total in the millions of dollars. However, apart from the purchase price, there are additional expenses like regular maintenance, software updates, and the recurring costs of disposable parts used in each surgery.

Learning curve

Secondly, the steep learning curve for operating these robotic systems requires intensive training for surgeons. This not only involves a time investment but also necessitates substantial training resources and costs. Plus, despite high-definition 3D visualization, some systems lack the tactile feedback a surgeon gets from traditional hands-on surgery. This can make robotic surgery feel different than traditional operations.

Longer surgeries

Another drawback can be the increased duration of surgeries, especially during the initial phase of robotic system implementation. This extends the time a patient spends under anesthesia, which can be a concern.

Legal and regulatory changes

Lastly, the legal and regulatory frameworks around robotic surgery are still evolving, with unresolved issues like liability in the event of complications during robot-assisted surgery. As the technology is still new, some healthcare providers might be hesitant to leverage the technology as they wait for more certainty around regulatory frameworks and liability.

While these challenges are significant, they do not outweigh the potential benefits of surgical robots. As this technology continues to evolve and mature, we can expect many of these limitations to be addressed.

What do surgical robots cost?

The cost of implementing a surgical robotic system is considerable and generally consists of two main components:

• Initial costs
• Ongoing costs

Initial costs primarily comprise the purchase price of the surgical robot, which can range in the millions of dollars. An average cost of a surgical robot is around $2 million (USD). This cost can fluctuate based on the specific capabilities of the robot, the range of procedures it can assist with, and the sophistication of its technology. Additionally, the initial costs often include the price of installation and comprehensive training for the surgical and support staff.

The ongoing costs of operating a surgical robot are also substantial. These include:

• Maintenance
• Consumables
• Software licensing and updates
• Surgery time

Regular maintenance ensures that the machine functions optimally. Replacing disposable instruments used in each surgery is also a necessary cost. Consumable costs can tally into thousands of dollars annually. Software updates, which are often necessary to keep the system functioning at its best and to integrate new features or enhancements, also add to the ongoing costs. Lastly, there are indirect costs, such as additional operating room time, particularly during the initial acclimation period to the robotic system.

However, while these costs are significant, they must be weighed against the potential benefits that surgical robots offer, including:

• Potential for reduced hospitalization time
• Fewer surgical complications
• Enhanced surgical precision

Despite the high cost, the surgical robot market is poised for sustained growth in the coming years as more healthcare institutions invest in this promising technology.

How big is the market for surgical robots?

The market for surgical robots has been growing rapidly in recent years and is projected to continue its upward trajectory. While the precise market size can vary depending on the source, as of 2023, it's generally agreed upon that the market is worth several billions of dollars and is experiencing double-digit growth rates annually. One report values the total market at $4.4 billion (USD) in 2022 and estimates a CAGR of 18% from 2023 to 2030.

What’s next?

You may be ready to take the next step toward automating your operating room, but where do you start?

The HowToRobot platform connects buyers of automation with a variety of suppliers in a streamlined, easy-to-use environment.

Post your project on HowToRobot today for free, and begin receiving offers from vetted and relevant automation vendors from our supplier network.

Learn about other types of healthcare robots.